World
Google apologises over US First Lady image
US First Lady Michelle Obama. Google has apologised over a racially offensive image of Michelle Obama which appears when users search for her images. Photo/REUTERS
Posted Wednesday, November 25 2009 at 11:39
In Summary
- Google refuses to take the image down from its search results.
- The White House has declined to comment.
Google has apologised over a racially offensive image of Michelle Obama which appears when users search for images of the US first lady.
The picture appears top of the Google Image search results for Mrs Obama.
Google placed a notice over the image titled "Offensive Search Results", saying: "Sometimes our search results can be offensive. We agree."
But it refused to take the image down from its search results. The White House has declined to comment.
Users who click on the notice above the image are directed to a statement from Google which explains that its results "can include disturbing content, even from innocuous queries".
"We apologise if you've had an upsetting experience using Google," the company says.
Google says a website's ranking in its search results relies heavily on computer algorithms, using thousands of factors to calculate a page's relevance to a given query.
But the search engine says it does not remove images simply because it receives complaints.
"Google views the integrity of our search results as an extremely important priority," it says.
"Accordingly, we do not remove a page from our search results simply because its content is unpopular or because we receive complaints concerning it."
However, the California-based web giant says it will take down certain images, if required by law to do so.
A spokesman for Google, Scott Rubin, would not give details on how the image ended up as the top result for Mrs Obama.
David Vise, a Pulitzer prize-winning journalist and author of The Google Story, told the BBC that Google results get to the top based on popularity, not because of any ranking system used by the search engine.
He added: "If Google got a call from the White House telling them it's against the law to have an offensive image of this kind which portrays the first lady in a racist manner as a monkey or an ape, then they would be obliged to take it down and I'm sure they would do so immediately."
But he said it would be a "very slippery slope" if Google were to try to police the limits of free speech.
-
Google is 100% responsible of this issue. They have full control of what goes in and out out from their huge global conglomerate. In conclusion, every little action has a reaction.
-
I don't think google should be blamed as they don't rank pages on their own but rely on some algorithm which does not discriminate. However, owner of the website should be reprimanded for assassinating the person of Michelle. It's up to the Obamas to see if they want to follow such route or to analyze whether it's is worth giving publicity to the website's bigot. Believe me there are countless BIGOTS here!
-
what next - the post office will have to apologise for delivering 'offensive' mail, even though they're not privy to its content? with greates erspect for the obamas, i don't understand why a search engine has to apologise for content it did not generate.




RSS