UN, aid agencies differ on number of S. Sudanese killed in civil war

South Sudanese civilians flee fighting in Malakal on February 18, 2016, where gunmen opened fire on civilians sheltering inside a United Nations base. The many ways people have died during South Sudan’s two-year civil war are well-documented, but the number killed is unknown. PHOTO | JUSTIN LYNCH |

What you need to know:

  • The many ways people have died during South Sudan’s two-year civil war are well-documented, but the number killed is unknown.
  • Men, women and children have been shot, speared, burnt, castrated, hung, drowned, run over, suffocated, starved and blown up, their corpses abandoned where they fell, bulldozed into mass graves or, in at least one case, eaten in ritual cannibalism.
  • But the United Nations has stuck to an estimate of 10,000 dead since the early months of the war, even as the killings spread across the country.
  • More than 30 aid workers have been killed since war broke out in December 2013.
  • The minimum figure of 50,000 is of those killed in direct conflict, but if those killed as a consequence of war are included the numbers skyrocket.

UBA, Friday

The many ways people have died during South Sudan’s two-year civil war are well-documented, but the number killed is unknown.

Men, women and children have been shot, speared, burnt, castrated, hung, drowned, run over, suffocated, starved and blown up, their corpses abandoned where they fell, bulldozed into mass graves or, in at least one case, eaten in ritual cannibalism.

But the United Nations has stuck to an estimate of 10,000 dead since the early months of the war, even as the killings spread across the country.

A year into the war, in November 2014, the International Crisis Group, which has closely tracked the fighting, said at least 50,000 had died.

This month, the UN finally caught up, quoting the same figure but over a two-year span.

FAILURE OF MORALITY

Sudan expert Eric Reeves, a professor at Smith College in the US, said not counting the dead was a failure of morality.

“If we give up on establishing mortality estimates we are, in one way or another, saying that the lives don’t really count,” he said.

Aid workers and officials who did not want to speak on the record said the true figure might be as high as 300,000 - a number comparable to those killed in Syria during five years of fighting.

“The level and intensity of violence has been above and beyond what we have seen almost anywhere else,” said one worker for an international aid agency which operates in multiple conflict zones, and who asked not to be named.

More than 30 aid workers have been killed since war broke out in December 2013.

The minimum figure of 50,000 is of those killed in direct conflict, but if those killed as a consequence of war are included the numbers skyrocket.

That would include starvation from aid blockades, such as the 40,000 people the UN warned last month were in catastrophic conditions - potentially famine, if the areas were not too dangerous to gather the data needed to declare it - as well as documented atrocities such as civilians suffocated in shipping containers.

It would also include those who died due to lack of healthcare following targeted destruction of hospitals.

Medicins Sans Frontiers has warned of far-reaching consequences for hundreds of thousands of people with six of its clinics and hospitals attacked, looted or torched - sometimes repeatedly.