alexa Google risks China's ire with slap to censorship - Daily Nation

Google risks China's ire with slap to censorship

Tuesday March 23 2010

Passengers sit in a double deck bus painted with a Google advertisement in Beijing March 23, 2010. Photo/REUTERS

Passengers sit in a double deck bus painted with a Google advertisement in Beijing March 23, 2010. Photo/REUTERS 


Google Inc shut its mainland Chinese-language portal and began rerouting searches to its Hong Kong-based site, unleashing a blast of ire from Beijing and prompting concerns over its future business in China.

China lost little time in warning Google that its rejection of self-censorship angered the one-party government, which is wary of ceding control over domestic use of the Internet with 384 million users in China.

Google's decision comes amid heightened tensions between Beijing and Washington over a range of issues, from Internet freedom to the yuan exchange rate, economic sanctions on Iran and U.S. weapons sales to Taiwan.

Google shocked the world and the business community in January when it announced it might quit China on censorship issues and after suffering from a sophisticated hacking attack that it said originated from within China.

Beijing has strongly denied it was involved in any hacking.

"Google has violated the written promise it made on entering the Chinese market," said an unnamed official from China's State Council Information Office, which helps oversee Internet rules, according to the Xinhua news agency.


"We firmly oppose politicizing commercial issues, and express our dissatisfaction and anger at Google Inc's unreasonable accusations and practices," said the official.

Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesman Qin Gang told a regular news conference that Google's move was an isolated act, and that relevant government departments would handle it in accordance with the law.

"The Google incident is the individual act of a commercial company. I don't see that it would have any impact on China-U.S. relations, unless some people want to politicize it," Qin said.

Those who were rerouted to Google's Hong Kong website,, were still unable to access sensitive websites, however, because China's government firewall continues to filter all content reaching the mainland.

Google said it intends to continue research and development in China, and keep sales staff there.

But the company is likely to be closely watched by officials, possibly emboldened after months of friction with Washington.

"I don't think it's sustainable for Google to conduct rerouting of traffic," said Edward Yu, chief executive of Analysys International, a Beijing-based research firm specializing in technology issues.

"The thing that makes the government unhappy is this kind of gesture. That Google will not follow (the rules), and that gesture will anger the government so they may set up barriers against Google."

Analysts said it was possible Google's plans for other services in China, such as its Android smartphone software, could be jeopardized by its move.

"Ordinary (Chinese) Internet users won't be much affected, because the only difference they'll see is that the burden of censorship has shifted from Google to the government," said Wang Junxiu, a Beijing-based Internet entrepreneur who has campaigned against online controls.

"But Google's business may take a hit. Advertising may fall, and (Chinese) companies that have invested in joining up with Google innovations and content will be hurt," said Wang.

An impasse

China gave no ground on the censorship issue in its dealings with Google, the company's Chief Legal Officer David Drummond wrote in a blog post on Monday.

The impasse was the most likely scenario as Google challenged China's ruling Communist Party who is wary of any political challenges in the world's third biggest economy.

Drummond also wrote that "the Chinese government has been crystal clear throughout our discussions that self-censorship is a non-negotiable legal requirement."

Searches on the Hong Kong Website from mainland broadband lines for sensitive news and discussion about jailed dissidents and banned organizations proved erratic.

Some searches gave links to sites that previously did not.

However, these pages could not be opened.

Other searches for the same sensitive topics just returned a blank page. can still be accessed from China.

But, as always, links for sensitive topics cannot be opened.

Google has steadily grown its market share since 2006 when it only had about 10 percent of the market.

While Google is the world's top search engine, it held only an estimated 30 percent share of China's search market in 2009, compared with home-grown rival Baidu Inc's 60 percent.

Google's decision on Monday, therefore, won't have an immediate impact on earnings, analysts say.

Shares of Google, which have fallen more than 6 percent since January when it announced plans to stop censoring searches in China, closed Monday's trading session down $2.50 at $557.60.

Shares of Baidu, which have soared more than 40 percent during the same period, finished up $10.07 at $579.72.

Google's troubles in China are not unique.

Many foreign companies such as eBay and Yahoo! have failed to make headway in the market due to localisation problems and stiff domestic competition and have pulled out.

China requires Internet operators inside the country to block words and images Beijing deems unacceptable. used such a filter.

Internationally popular websites Facebook, Twitter and Google's YouTube are blocked in China.

Google said it was "entirely legal" for it to re-route traffic to an uncensored Hong Kong site.

A former British colony, Hong Kong is a special administrative region of China and enjoys more freedom, including an uncensored Internet, than mainland China.

However, Google acknowledged that the Chinese government could at any time block access to the services, which include Google search, news and images.

Analysts said Google's other business units, such as its Android platform, may be at risk in China, if the mobile phones offer Google search services that reroute to Hong Kong.

"The most important thing is whether in their search results in China, there is content that is not in line with China's policy. If there still is, I think that their businesses will have an unstable outlook," said Cao Junbo, chief analyst at iResearch.